ADVERTISEMENT

Homeowners Respond To Energy Efficiency Thresholds When Investing In Home Retrofits

Ireland has a system to grade the energy efficiency of residential buildings, called a Building Energy Rating (BER). A BER is a standardized assessment of a property’s energy requirements for space and water heating, ventilation, and lighting, fewer savings from energy generation technologies.

It is calculated in terms of kWh/m2/year of energy consumption from which a grade is assigned. The grade is from a 15-point scale ranging from A1 to G, with A1 being the most energy efficient. An example BER certificate is contained in Figure 1.

ADVERTISEMENT
Fig. 1 Copyright 2018 Elsevier, all rights reserved

A home with a high level of energy efficiency generally has lower energy costs for space and water heating compared to similar properties with low energy efficiency. Such properties are also considered more comfortable; for example, they may have fewer drafts, or it is easier to keep them warm.  The value of these benefits has been capitalized upon in house prices and rental values with each point improvement along the 15-point BER scale associated with approximately a 1% higher price or a 0.5% increase in rental value [1,2].

The distribution of BER ratings from A1 to G is not quite a bell-shaped distribution, as there are more energy inefficient than energy efficient properties, but the distribution is relatively “smooth,” as illustrated in Figure 2.

Fig. 2 Copyright 2018 Elsevier, all rights reserved

A government grant is available to homeowners to improve the energy efficiency of their properties via a range of measures such as attic or wall insulation, high-efficiency boiler installation, or heating control upgrades. When we look at the distribution of BER ratings of properties that have received the government grant, the distribution is no longer “smooth” and there are obvious spikes or bunching in the BER distribution on the “better” side of the letter ratings, as shown in Figure 3.

Fig. 3 Copyright 2018 Elsevier, all rights reserved

The key question of interest is what is the cause of the bunching? Are homeowners and BER assessors fraudulently upgrading BER ratings to secure the benefits of higher property prices associated with better BER grades? Or, alternatively, are the letter grades encouraging homeowners to achieve the best possible energy efficiency rating when upgrading their homes? The research paper investigates this issue and finds that 4.5% of BER assessments (and energy retrofit grant recipients) occur in these bunching areas on the favorable side of the BER letter threshold.

ADVERTISEMENT

The bunching is strongest at thresholds corresponding to a change in letter grade, with the highest levels of relative bunching occurring at the B3/C1, C3/D1, D2/E1 and F/G thresholds. This suggests that greater emphasis is placed on a property achieving a more favorable letter grade assessment than achieving a more favorable alpha-numeric grade within a specific letter grading, e.g. C2 versus C3.

Understanding whether the bunching is real and reflects accurate assessments of properties’ energy performance or the result of illicit activity is important. If the bunching reflects reality then dividing the continuous BER rating (in kWh/m2/year) into a 15-point scale has achieved a beneficial outcome of encouraging home-owners to upgrade their homes beyond the next attainable threshold. If the bunching represents illicit activity the associated price premiums constitute a fraud on buyers or renters.

If the bunching is due to illicit activity, it will be associated with specific BER assessors, but there is no empirical evidence that any specific BER assessors are more likely to have graded properties in these ‚Äėbunched‚Äô BERs. What the analysis does find is that there is a close link between BER assessments in these bunching areas and higher installations of energy efficient lighting. Due to its relatively low cost and ease of installation, low-energy lighting is an obvious route for homeowners to follow to ensure their BER assessment occurs on the favorable side of the BER letter threshold.

While the analysis is specific to building energy ratings in Ireland, there are lessons for other countries. The presence of bunching in Irish BER ratings suggests that clearly identifiable thresholds within a continuous rating scale (i.e. kWh/m2/year) provides an incentive to homeowners to surpass the thresholds when they invest in home retrofits.

These findings are described in the article, and Figures 1, 2 and 3 reprinted from Applied Energy, 211, Matthew Collins and John Curtis, Bunching of residential building energy performance certificates at threshold values, pages 662‚Äď676, Copyright (2018), with permission from Elsevier.¬†This work was conducted by Matthew Collins and John Curtis from The Economic and Social Research Institute.

ADVERTISEMENT

References:

  1. Hyland M, Lyons RC, Lyons S. The value of domestic building energy efficiency: evidence from Ireland. Energy Economics 2013;40:943‚Äď52. https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0140988313001655.
  2. Stanley S, Lyons RC, Lyons S. The price effect of building energy ratings in the Dublin residential market. Energy Efficiency 2016;9(4):875‚Äď85. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs12053-015-9396-5.

Comments

READ THIS NEXT

Jack Of All Trades Or Master Of One? Answers From Fossils And Dog Poop

Which will be more successful: an animal with a flexible diet or an animal that eats meat only or plants […]

Citrine: Characteristics And Properties

Citrine is an incredible mineral variety of quartz with interesting properties and characteristics.¬†Citrine is a quartz characterized by its yellow […]

Lunar Floor-Fractured Craters Provide Evidence For Ancient Magmatic Intrusions

Molten rock (magma) is generated in planetary interiors and rises toward the surface, sometimes cooling and freezing before it gets […]

Chilean Geysers And Hotsprings As Source Of Thermotolerant Microbial Phytases

Chile is well known as a volcanic country with a huge variety of pristine and extreme environments. Chilean extreme environments, […]

Ultrasmall Nanoplatelets: The Ultimate Tuning Of Optoelectronic Properties

¬†Semiconductor nanocrystals with unique optoelectronic properties have emerged as promising materials for applications in solar technologies, including solar cells, solar-driven […]

Research Reports Bacteria Harpoon New DNA To Speed Evolution

Bacteria are known for their ability to rapidly evolve and respond to new threats, which is why drug-resistant bacteria have […]

Restored Oxbows As A Nutrient Reduction Practice In The Agricultural Midwest

Nutrient export from the Corn Belt of the United States is impacting rivers at local and regional scales and is […]

Science Trends is a popular source of science news and education around the world. We cover everything from solar power cell technology to climate change to cancer research. We help hundreds of thousands of people every month learn about the world we live in and the latest scientific breakthroughs. Want to know more?