An Analysis Of The Unique Timbre Of The Portuguese Guitar

The Portuguese guitar is a specific type of guitar which was developed in Portugal during the last centuries, directly descending from the European Cittern. It is a pear-shaped chordophone with six double course strings and it requires a distinctive plucking technique to be played.

The most common versions relate to Lisbon, where Fado takes the main role of its use, and Coimbra, where students from the oldest Portuguese university have used its tones to sustain their academic rhythms.

Playing the Portuguese guitar. Credit: Mario Vieira

As the sound generation from chordophones is intrinsically connected to the interaction between string vibration and the guitar structure (most usually the top soundboard), the acknowledgment of the dynamic behavior of these instruments enables the craft of better and more objective-focused guitars.

Classical guitars have been the focus of extensive research on their dynamic behavior; on the other hand, the Portuguese guitar, as a result of being mostly confined to Portugal, has been the focus of less research and, therefore, the secrets of its dynamic characteristics, which relate to its unique timbre, are yet to be discovered.

Third computational mode of the portuguese guitar

A research was produced by a group of researchers from IST, Lisbon, where the correlation between the experimental dynamic behavior of the guitar and its correspondent computational behavior was obtained. The experimental data, which had been previously obtained, was gathered using adequate dynamic equipment for an experimental modal description of mechanical structures. During these experimental procedures, the guitar, which is suspended mid-air by a cable, is excited through an instrumented hammer; on the other hand, accelerometers register the consequent vibrations of the structure. The post-processing of this data allows the experimental description of the dynamic behavior of the guitar.

Figure 2 – Apparatus of the experimental setup for the guitar modal characterization, with two installed accelerometers (one per plate) and the instrumented hammer. Credit: Mario Vieira

The generation of the computational model of the Portuguese guitar raised a series of challenges, notably due to its complex geometry, inability to acknowledge the used woods and the difficult access to the reinforcements inside the air chamber. Therefore, different methodologies were employed. For wood acknowledgment, several guitar players and luthiers were contacted to obtain their opinion based on their settled experience. For the geometry definition of the tested guitar, visual inspection, radiography techniques, and 3D-scanning tools were used in order to describe, with the best detail possible, its complete geometry.

Figure 3 – One of the obtained radiographies for the analysis of the internal structure of the guitar. Credit: Mario Vieira
Figure 4 – 3D Digitalization of the tested guitar. Credit: Mario Vieira
Figure 5 – Point cloud obtained from the 3D scanning. Credit: Mario Vieira

Modeling of the guitar was then produced using an adequate CAD software; in this specific case, Solidworks.

Figure 6 – Final CAD model of the guitar, with the internal reinforcements. Credit: Mario Vieira

The model was then exported to a relevant finite element model software, ANSYS Workbench 15. The produced analyzes did not only consist of structural modal ones; in fact, in this research, we have also used a vibro-acoustic model, where the air inside the guitar chamber was also considered. The consideration of the air which is inside the chamber has shown to be crucial by several previous types of research, both experimental and computational. In reality, the non-consideration of the air inside the chamber results in mismatches between the experimental and computational behavior, most especially at lower frequencies of vibration (up to 300 Hz).

Figure 7 – Finite element mesh for the air inside the chamber and the guitar structure, for a total of 784256 finite elements. Credit: Mario Vieira

The obtained results confirmed that considering the air inside the chamber was utmost necessary to obtain a good correlation between the experimental and computational data; from the 17 modes that were experimentally described, the structural model only detected 10; the vibroacoustic model was able to detect 14. The difference is particularly relevant at the low-frequency modes since they are usually very dependent on the air-structure coupling; furthermore, these low-frequency modes tend to possess a prominent influence on the quantity and quality of the generated sound.

This research is fundamental as it is one of the first of its kind to evaluate the dynamic behavior of the Portuguese guitar using the most advanced finite element methods in the world. Furthermore, the use of these models will provide the Portuguese guitar luthiers with a tool which will allow them to improve the crafting of their instruments; either for general purposes or to tune a specific instrument to a certain tone.

These findings are described in the article entitled Experimental-numerical correlation of the dynamic behavior of the Portuguese guitar, recently published in the journal Applied Acoustics. This work was conducted by M. Vieira, V. Infante, P. Serrão, and A. M. R. Ribeiro from Universidade de Lisboa.

About The Author

Mário Vieira

Mário Vieira is a PhD Candidate at MIT Portugal Program: Focusing on the Feasibility of Structural Health Monitoring Systems for Offshore Wind Supporting Structures. Mechanical Engineering Researcher at IDMEC, IST, Lisbon: Very High Cycle Fatigue Testing, Mechanical Design, Mechanical Behavior of Materials.

Speak Your Mind!

READ THIS NEXT

An Alternative To Petroleum-Based Plastic Packaging

Packaging is a crucial tool in containing and protecting food as it moves through the supply chain to the consumer. The main function of packaging is to protect the product and extend the shelf life of food. Food packaging materials have been traditionally based on petroleum-based plastics due to their versatile and durable nature with […]

In Just 4 Hours, Google’s AI Mastered All The Chess Knowledge in History

The field of artificial intelligence has grown by leaps and bounds over the past couple decades advance, and now an AI called AlphaZero has taught itself to play chess with a superhuman level of knowledge in just a few hours. AlphaZero is a game-playing AI program derived from DeepMind’s AlphaGo. AlphaGo made headlines last year […]

Fossil Beetles From Cretaceous Amber Show New Insights Into Early Plant-Insect Relationships

Coleoptera, commonly known as “beetles,” with about 400,000 species, is the largest order in nature, constituting almost 40% of described insects and 25% of all known animal life-forms. The extraordinary species richness probably resulted by their elevated survival of lineages and their sustained diversification in a variety of niches (Hunt et al., 2007). Beetles are […]

Avoiding Pitfalls In Periodic Orbits of Maps With A Piecewise Approach

Numerical computation is widely recognized to be of great importance in many fields of science. Many conclusions in nonlinear science and complex systems have been drawn upon simulation on a digital computer. Although this importance is widely recognized, the way of computers work is, in general, not known in detail. Let us start our discussion […]

COF-1 As A 2-D Material With Promising Applications

The quest for two-dimensional (2D) materials, starting with graphene in 2004, remains strong. While graphene retains the title of strongest solid, intense research has shown that it is not suited for every use. For example, turning off the current flowing through graphene transistors has proven quite a challenge. Moreover, high-quality graphene lacks pores, which prevents […]

Novel Organic Sodium-Ion Batteries Could Be Charged As Fast As Supercapacitors

Lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) are the most popular power supply for portable electronic devices (such as mobile phones and computers) and electric vehicles. However, most of the commercial lithium-ion batteries are based on rigid inorganic materials, which are facing the challenges and shortcomings including low capacity, resource scarcity, undegradability, slow charging rate, and low cyclability. Now, […]

What Is The Red Material Found On Uranus’ Moons?

The seventh most distant planet in our Solar System, Uranus, is orbited by the mid-sized regular satellites Miranda, Ariel, Umbriel, Titania, and Oberon (Figure 1). The innermost moon Miranda is the smallest (diameter 472 km), the middle moons Ariel and Umbriel are also the middle two in terms of size (diameters of 1158 km and […]