The Relationship Between Wild Ungulates And Temperate Forests

Wild ungulates such as deer, moose, goats, and boar are key drivers of forest ecosystems, as they can exert strong top-down control on forest structure and dynamics by numerous mechanisms which include rubbing their antlers on trees, stripping bark from tree trunks, and feeding on tree shoots and roots.

At the same time, the current increase of ungulate density across the northern hemisphere because of ungulate reintroduction programs, abandonment of agricultural land, competitive release from domestic ungulates, the absence of top predators, and improvement of habitat quality has exacerbated the top-down control that these animals have over the forest, hence, compromising the conservation of biodiverse forests for future generations.

Understanding the impacts of ungulate density is important in order to prevent shifts towards undesired states, such as from forest to heathland.

Wild boar in the Netherlands. Photo credit: Juan Ignacio Ramirez

With our research, we assess the effects of ungulate density on forest regeneration, development, and functioning. We carried out a systematic literature review of over 400 published studies in temperate forests and used the data to model dose-response curves of the effects of ungulate density on three sets of forest attributes: tree regeneration (abundance, species richness, and composition), forest structure (horizontal and vertical), and forest functioning (nutrient cycling in soil, timber, and food production).  Ungulate density averaged at 23.6 animals per km-2 across studies and had a negative effect on forest regeneration, structure, and function in 70% of the evaluated cases. The shape of the dose-response curves was sigmoidal, rather than a unimodal shape.

Critical tipping points, where ungulates started to have a negative effect on forest regeneration, were found at an ungulate metabolic weight density of 115 kg km-2 for forest regeneration, 141 kg km-2 for forest structure, and 251 kg km-2 for forest functioning, which is roughly equivalent to 10, 13 and 23 roe deer per km-2. Forest regeneration was most sensitive to immediate browsing and trampling impacts of small seedlings, while forest functioning was least sensitive because of time lags. However, these effects may build up over time.

Forest managers can improve forest heterogeneity by (1) setting up ungulate exclosures at different temporal and spatial scale, (2) by offering alternative foliage for ungulates, (3) limiting the number of reproductive females, and (4) by reintroducing top predators.

Exclosure in the Netherlands. Photo credit: Juan Ignacio Ramirez

Rewilding natural areas with apex predators might bring ungulate density into balance again and thus secure regeneration establishment and development. Predators can eventually restore top-down interactions and associated cascading effects that culling and game hunting has failed to achieve. In natural areas, trophic rewilding gives the opportunity of self-regulation, thus providing new opportunities for the entire ecological community and reducing human interference.

These findings are described in the article entitled Effects of wild ungulates on the regeneration, structure and functioning of temperate forests: A semi-quantitative review, recently published in the journal Forest Ecology and Management. This work was conducted by J. Ignacio Ramirez and Lourens Poorter from Wageningen University & Research, and Patrick A. Jansen from Wageningen University & Research and the Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute.

About The Author

Juan Ignacio Ramirez

Juan Ignacio Ramirez currently works at the Department of Forest Ecology and Forest Management Group, Wageningen University & Research. Juan Ignacio does research in Ecology. Their current project is 'The role of wild ungulates on temperate forests'.

Speak Your Mind!

READ THIS NEXT

Large Scale Lifestyle Study Suggests Coffee Good For Your Health

Coffee is one of the most commonly consumed beverages in the world, with millions of people enjoying the boost they receive from the caffeine in the coffee. A new large-scale lifestyle and health study may have some good news for these people, suggesting that coffee may have a variety of health benefits including lowering risk […]

Modeling Collective Animal Behaviors And Decision Making

Every day there are flocks of birds, schools of fish, and colonies of ants, etc. that all exhibit the amazing power to move coherently together, to make a smart collective choice. How can they do it? This question has inspired generations of scientists to investigate this phenomenon- called collective animal behaviors. In recent literature, the […]

Linking Anemia To Porotic Hyperostosis In Archaeological Remains

Porotic hyperostosis is one of the most common skeletal conditions observed in archaeological remains. It is a term that refers to porous lesions occurring on bones of either or both the cranium and/or post-cranium. When these same lesions specifically appear on the orbital roof or eye sockets, it is called cribra orbitalia. Despite differing locations […]

The Uses Of Computers: Work And Personal

No recent invention has changed modern human life nearly as much as the computer. Since their invention in 1939, digital computers have become¬†a mainstay of virtually every aspect of human life. Computers¬†are used to modulate and handle a number of tasks from a staggering amount of domains: businesses, city infrastructure, scientific research, automobiles, household appliances, […]

Hot Temperature Has Highest Mortality Risk, But Moderately Cold Temperature Contributed To The Most Deaths In India

Extreme temperatures, including cold spells and heat waves, have detrimental effects on human health. Most climate change projections foresee extreme weather becoming more prevalent. Indeed, various parts of the world have already begun to experience the impact of extremely hot weather. Much less attention has been given to the health effects of cold temperature ranges. […]

Fossil Fuel Pros And Cons

Fossil fuel pros and cons can be separated into inexpensive, globally available, and compatibility with energy systems for fossil fuels pros compared to greenhouse gas emissions, finite resource, and environmentally damaging for fossil fuels cons. There is an ongoing debate on the different kinds of fuel. Today, we want to talk about the fossil fuels […]

Vectorial Statistics Of Wind Direction ‚Äď A New Type Of Statistics?

When people think about measurable variables, such as height and age, it is frequently assumed that they can be represented on the real line. For such variables, it is easy to obtain a measure of the average that is defined as the sum of the values divided by the number of values. It is also […]