Examining Parasitoid Effects On Aphid Populations In Québec

Insect pest populations are known to be regulated, at least in part, by naturally-occurring natural enemies such as pathogens, predators, and parasitoids — the latter living at the expense of their host, like parasites, but eventually killing it. Natural enemies have the advantage to exert a prolonged pressure on pest populations. They maintain pest densities at low levels, thereby preventing insecticide applications. Properly quantifying the impact of pest management strategies is of utmost importance in agriculture to ensure they are both economically advantageous as well as reliable. However, assessing the impact of natural enemies on insect pests is usually much more complex than for insecticides.

This article focuses on aphid control by parasitoids. Aphids belong to a large group of small, sap-sucking, insects that reproduce fast and includes important pests of various crops. Aphid parasitoids are tiny wasps often used as biological control agents. Adult females lay a single egg inside their host and the emerging larvae feed on the aphid, which remains alive until the parasitoid enters the last stage of its immature development. The aphid is then killed and its cuticle expands, hardens, and becomes beige or black. The swollen aphid, called a mummy, protects the pupating parasitoid until its emergence as an adult.

From an experimental perspective, mummies represent a record of the parasitoid-induced aphid mortality and, therefore, facilitate biological control studies. The proportion of parasitized aphids (mummies) is often used directly to quantify the capacity of parasitoids to control aphid populations. However, although this approach provides instantaneous measures of mortality, it does not consider the consequences on subsequent aphid generations and, thereby, the long-term impact of natural enemies.

The Propagated Mortality Analysis

In the first part of the article, we developed an inferential method, designated as the propagated mortality analysis (PMA), to assess the impact that parasitoids have on aphid populations in open fields. More specifically, the PMA allows translating observed mortality rates into their impact on forthcoming aphid populations and into estimates of control that are useful in the decision to intervene.

The method relies on the fact that many aphid species have a single peak of abundance in annual crops during the summer. This population dynamics holds even in absence of natural enemies and tend to be driven by bottom-up effects such as the plant quality, which changes throughout the season. We modified an existing model describing this population dynamics to incorporate the influence of parasitoid-induced mortality on aphid populations. Being able to compare an aphid population in the presence versus the absence of parasitoids allows us to estimate their impact at any time during the season.

To facilitate interpreting the impact of parasitoids, we provided two estimates of control. We first evaluated the decrease in aphid populations due to parasitoids at peak aphid density, because producers and agronomists often want to know if pest populations will reach some intervention thresholds. We next calculated the decrease in aphid populations, associated to the parasitoid, in terms of cumulative aphid densities (CAD) over the period during which the crop is susceptible to aphids. The latter estimate of control was considered because yield loss is often calculated from CAD. The economic value of naturally occurring parasitoids can, therefore, be assessed in terms of crop protection benefits.

The method can be used for any aphid system and only requires measuring aphid density and the proportion of parasitized aphids in the field, as well as knowledge of parasitoid developmental time. We encourage the use of PMA by making the R code available for its implementation.

The Case Study

In the second part of the article, we used PMA to assess the impact of a naturally occurring parasitoid species, Aphelinus sp., on the soybean aphid in Québec soybean fields. The method showed both the peak aphid density and the CAD to be reduced only between 1-7% by the parasitoid and to translate into crop protection values of less than 1%. Low control was associated to the late arrival of the parasitoid in the field, compared to the soybean aphid, while low crop protection value arises from that the soybean aphid only slightly reduces soybean yields at usual densities in Québec.

Perspectives

The strength of PMA relies on its ability to assess parasitoid impact independently of its seasonal abundance. Therefore, the method opens the path to compare the efficacy of natural enemies that exhibit different patterns of colonization and foraging strategies. Given the accessibility of the method, we hope PMA will be used to quantify ecosystem services as well as to strengthen the predictability of control of mass-reared parasitoids and the establishment of release strategies.

These findings are described in the article entitled Estimating parasitoid impact on aphid populations in the field, recently published in the journal Biological ControlThis work was conducted by Alexandre Leblanc and Jacques Brodeur from the Université de Montréal.

About The Author

Alexandre Leblanc

Alexandre Leblanc is an Associate Professor at the Dept. of Statistics at the University of Manitoba.

Jacques Brodeur

Jacques Brodeur is a Canadian biologist, currently a Canada Research Chair in Biocontrol at Université de Montréal

Speak Your Mind!

READ THIS NEXT

Novel Antivirals For Venezuelan Equine Encephalitis

The Alphavirus Venezuelan equine encephalitis virus (VEEV) was first identified as the causative agent of an equine disease in 1938 and later was found to be a human pathogen.  While endemic strains circulating in rodents are generally unable to cause disease in humans, mutations in certain VEEV subtypes can create an epizootic strain, carried by […]

Moon Phase Today: A Simple Trick To Figure Out Today’s Moon Phase

An easy trick to remember what moon phase the moon is in on any given night is the mnemonic DOC. DOC, (or COD if you’re in the southern hemisphere), reflects the amount of the moon illuminated, which you can use to discern the current phase the moon is in. DOC represents the half moon, the […]

Why Are There More Species Packed In Some Places Than Others, And Why Does It Matter?

THE QUESTION Biodiversity  – the richness of species found at a given location – is critical to maintaining ecological processes and the benefits provided to humans by natural ecosystems. It is, therefore, extremely important to understand what causes biodiversity to vary in space and time. A century-old quest in this line of inquiry is to […]

How ICT Can Create A Difference For Northern Communities

The three territories of Canada cover 40% of the total area with a population less than half a percent of the country. Providing service and opportunities to grow in this remote, vast plain has been difficult due to multiple ecological and socioeconomic aspects. Telecommunication facilities are vital to economic activity, market development, and governance. They […]

Functions Of The Golgi Body

The Golgi body, also sometimes referred to as the Golgi apparatus or Golgi complex, is an intracellular organelle that is responsible for the packaging and transport of protein products. Proteins that are manufactured in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) are sent to the Golgi body, where they are then modified and sent off for secretion via exocytosis. In many […]

Cryptic Diversity In Vietnam’s Limestone Karst Habitats

The picturesque limestone karsts of northern Vietnam harbor a rich diversity of animals and plants. Due to their scattered distribution, these karsts can form terrestrial habitat islands for organisms that depend on a calcium-rich environment. Today, many karst habitats are threatened, notably due to the extraction of limestone for the production of construction materials such […]

Antioxidant Treatment To Block Lung Inflammation Caused By Cigarette Smoke

Smoking is a harmful addiction responsible for several lung pathologies caused by toxicity of the cigarette smoke. One of them is chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), characterized by a chronic cough, respiratory secretions, and progressive dyspnea and fibrosis, produced by chronic exposure of susceptible individuals to cigarette smoke (CS).  In addition to cigarette smoke, other factors […]