How Public Opinion Affects Air Quality: A Chinese Case Study

China has achieved notable economic development in recent decades. However, such achievement comes with serious environmental and social costs. The issue of environmental deterioration, particularly air pollution, has drawn extensive concern from the public as well as policymakers and scholars.

In early 2012, the Chinese government released documents requiring the adoption of a new standard for Air Quality Index (AQI), which addresses the concentrations of air pollutants including PM2.5, PM10, ozone (O3), sulfur dioxide (SO2), etc., and their constant updates and publication on media. However, frequent high levels of AQI have become a grievance of the public and drawn media critiques. Even though China is an authoritarian country with strict media control, with the rapid development and application of information and internet technologies, it is increasingly difficult to limit public opinion. Therefore, public opinion can put great pressure on the government and force it to take actions to regulate air pollution.

We intended to examine whether and how public opinion on air quality, specifically smog, affects air quality. This is the first study to quantitatively examine the influence of public opinion on air quality in China. We addressed the questions from three aspects: 1. to examine the connection between the change in air quality and the formation of public opinion; 2. to examine the extent to and the pace at which public opinion affects air quality once it is formed; and 3. to examine the details of the influence of public opinion on the concentrations of individual air pollutants.

We utilized monthly data from 109 prefecture-level cities in China from November 2013 to October 2016. Air quality data included AQI, concentrations indexes of PM2.5, PM10, O3, SO2, carbon monoxide (CO), and nitrogen dioxide (NO2), and the numbers of days with rain or snow and wind of grade 3 or above. The dataset of public opinion consisted of the numbers of online mainstream media commentaries related to smog issue and were collected from national and local media sources. We then calculated the monthly intensity of public opinion that is the weighted average numbers of the media reports from national, provincial, and local media sources. In addition, we grouped the cities for comparison and contrast based on the proportion of secondary industrial output values, per-capita GDP, the size of the population, and geographical location.

First, we analyzed the formation of public opinion and found that the deterioration of air quality can cause the outbreak of public opinion. In addition, subsample regression results showed that in cities with higher values for secondary industrial output, higher per-capita GDP, larger population, and that are located in Northern China, public opinion reacted more sensitively to the level of AQI. Furthermore, it is statistically confirmed that if the city is a provincial capital, or if it is in Middle or Western China, public opinion may be formed more quickly. It is also worth noting that in October, November, and December, public opinion occurred more frequently.

To address the second question, we analyzed the temporal difference of the impact of public opinion and concluded that public opinion that has been formed for a long period may have limited impact, while a recent one is more likely to induce governmental regulatory actions. Therefore, we emphasized the recent public opinion and conducted statistic estimations to examine to what extent and at what pace public opinion affects air quality, which we call the ameliorating effect and decelerating effect, respectively.

Two models were utilized to examine these effects after proper adjustments. Regression results based on both models showed that the one- and two-period lags of public opinion exhibited significant negative effects on air quality indicators, which implies that up to two months after its formation, public opinion does reduce the level of air pollution, or it prevents air quality from worsening.

Interestingly, the three-period lag of public opinion had a positive effect on air quality, although the results are mostly not statistically significant. Such may be caused by the retaliatory rebound of air pollution near and after the relief of the pressure from public opinion. The regression results from contrasting groups show that both effects are relatively distinct in cities with a larger proportion of secondary industrial output value, higher GDP per capita, less population, and that are in Northern China.

Last but not least, we applied the models to examine both ameliorating and decelerating effects on each individual air pollutant to capture the effectiveness of public opinion on controlling individual air pollutants. What we mainly found from the estimations was that public opinion functions well in controlling PM2.5 and PM10, while it was not necessarily effective in controlling the others. Considering the fact that the majority of PM2.5 and PM10 emission comes from industrial production and construction activities, they are relatively manageable for governments through short-term regulations. SO2 and O3 are both mainly the byproducts of coal-fired power plants and coal boilers or furnaces, which are somewhat controllable. However, controlling the sources of emissions of CO and NO2 is more difficult since the major sources of them are automobile exhaust, and government cannot strictly regulate the use of automobiles.

In summary, we examined the effect of public opinion on air quality in terms of both “extent” and “pace” using monthly data of 109 prefecture-level cities in China from November 2013 to October 2016. The statistical results show that public opinion has both ameliorating and decelerating effects within two months after its formation. In addition, both effects exhibit variations with respect to the industrial structure, stage of economic development, population, and geological location of cities. Furthermore, examinations on individual air pollutants show that public opinion is effective in controlling PM2.5 and PM10 but less effective for other pollutants.

Our findings suggest that firstly, the government should address and respond to public opinion by regulating the sources of air pollution. Secondly, public opinion can be a criterion in evaluating local policymakers’ performance in order to supervise leaders’ environmental efforts. Thirdly, public opinion may serve as an indicator to help governments to identify the source, composition, and controllability of air pollution.

It is necessary to notice that the study in this paper still requires future development, such as the expansion of sampling cities and periods and utilizing other methods to address the possible correlation between economic development and the effectiveness of public opinion on air quality.

These findings are described in the article entitled Does public opinion affect air quality? Evidence based on the monthly data of 109 prefecture-level cities in China, recently published in the journal Energy Policy. This work was conducted by Shengling Zhang, Yue Li, and Yipeng Zhang from Beijing Normal University, and Yu Hao from the Beijing Institute of Technology, Sustainable Development Research Institute for Economy and Society of Beijing, and Beijing Key Lab of Energy Economics and Environmental Management.

About The Author

Yipeng Zhang

Yipeng Zhang is a researcher affiliated with Beijing Normal University at the School of Economics and Resource Management. His work focuses on public perceptions of pollution and air quality.

Speak Your Mind!


Analogous Structures: Definition And Examples

Analogous structures are structures which serve similar purposes yet are found in species that have come from different evolutionary lines. The study of analogous structures is a type of anatomical comparison between two different species, used to gain evidence for convergent evolution. How are analogous structures used to gain evidence for convergent evolution and what […]

90% Of Drinking Bottled Water Could Contain Microplastics

Bottled water has become an alternative to running water for many people around the world. There is a general belief that bottled water is healthier than running water in most places. But recently, the WHO has found that 90% of bottled water contains microplastics. According to The Guardian, there is currently a review by the […]

A Nano Solution To Identify Harmful S. Mutans Biofilm

The oral environment harbors both benign and malign bacteria, just like everywhere else in the body. The chances of developing dental cavities increase when one of these malicious bacteria called “Streptococcus mutans” (aka S. mutans) becomes dominant. This situation occurs if the bacteria live in a highly-structured community where they can send out signals to one […]

Tuning The State-Of-The-Art Numerical Simulator To Recover Energy From Methane Hydrates

With the ever-increasing demand for cleaner energy, natural gas is playing a growing role in the global energy mix replacing coal and oil to help transition into a future carbon-constrained world. Methane hydrates (MHs) have been considered as the potential future resource of energy due to its abundant resource volume of CH4 (20,000 trillion cubic […]

Classifying Sesame Oil Seed Varieties And Origins Using Mass Spectrometry

The quality and authenticity of vegetable oils are of importance not only for their nutritional value but also for their miscellaneous biomedical and industrial applications. Hence, the knowledge of their main constituents, triacylglycerols (TAGs), is mandatory for classification and adulteration detection. However, the analysis of TAG composition of vegetable oils is a challenging task because […]

Replacing Roast Masters With Mechanized Monitoring Systems For Coffee Roasting

Coffee roasting in an industrial plant represents one of the most critical issues in the food industry, as the final flavor of the beverage will strongly depend on the choice of the right blend of raw materials coming from different countries and the right end-time of the process. Although wet and dry post-harvesting processes of […]

What Elements Are In Lipids?

Lipids are macromolecules, large organic molecules, that carry out many different functions needed for life. Lipids function to store energy, compose the membrane of cells, and act as chemical signalers. In terms of the elements found in lipids, all lipids contain oxygen, hydrogen, and carbon. Some lipids also contain phosphorus and nitrogen. The elements that […]