How An Echolocating Bat’s Brain May Solve The Microsecond Timing Problem

On summer evenings, before it gets completely dark, you may have spotted some flying creatures overhead. Although these creatures could be swallows or other birds out at dusk, there is a good chance that they are bats, the only mammals capable of powered flight. Worldwide, there are >1,300 species of bats, ranging in size from a mere 2 grams to >1 kilogram (Fenton and Simmons, 2014). Of the many features that distinguish bats from other mammals, their use of echolocation has captured the imagination of scientists and the general public alike.

Echolocating animals actively interrogate their surroundings by producing intense, high-frequency sounds and listening to echoes reflecting from objects, see Figure 1 (Griffin, 1958). Echolocation enables bats to extract rich information about objects in the environment, such as the size, direction, and distance of insect prey. Although many insect prey, such as mosquitoes, are only millimeters in size, bats can use echolocation to localize, track, and catch them with ease. Echolocating bats compute the distance to prey by analyzing the elapsed time between emitted calls and echo returns, and they can discriminate target range differences of less than a centimeter. This suggests that bats can determine echo delay with a precision of 60 microseconds or higher. Indeed, over the past few decades, scientists have demonstrated microsecond precision of echo delay measurement in several species of bats (Moss and Schnitzler, 1995; Simmons, 1973). Yet, the big puzzle remains: how can the bat’s brain compute echo delay with such high precision?

One key structure in the auditory system that appears to play a role in the temporal analysis of sound is the inferior colliculus (IC), a midbrain structure found in all mammals. Leading bat neurophysiologists, such as Nobuo Suga and James A. Simmons, have all emphasized the potential importance of the IC in echolocation tasks (Simmons, 2017; Suga, 2015). Following this line of reasoning, Luo and colleagues (2018) investigated temporal processing of sound in the IC of the big brown bat, Eptesicus fuscus (Luo et al., 2018). Specifically, they focused their analyses on the timing of neural responses to echolocation sounds. Rather than measure the timing of action potentials of single neurons, they investigated the precision of extracellular field potentials (EFP’s) that arise from the synchronized activity of populations of neurons. They were surprised to discover that EFP’s exhibited remarkable temporal precision to simulated echolocation calls (Figure 1).

Figure 1: This image shows the big brown bat, Eptesicus fuscus, using echolocation to measure the distance to insect prey. This task requires the brain to compute the time difference between the emitted call and the echo return with microsecond precision. A neural timer with a precision of ~20 µs operates in the auditory midbrain of the bat. Image courtesy Jinhong Luo.

To mechanistically understand how these high-precision EFP’s were generated, Jinhong Luo and Cynthia F. Moss established collaborations with a group of computational neuroscientists, Torbjørn V. Ness and Gaute T. Einevoll at the Norwegian University of Life Sciences and Kechen Zhang at the Johns Hopkins University. Through mathematical modeling, the researchers showed that EFP’s in the bat IC arose from the synchronous firing of a population of neurons, and, importantly, the temporal precision of the EFP’s increased with an increase in the number of firing neurons.

To further explore the functional significance of EFP’s in bat echolocation, the researchers systematically varied the sound parameters of the echolocation calls, including the sound duration and the frequency bandwidth. They found that the highest temporal precision of EFP’s was evoked by echolocation calls of the shortest sound duration and the broadest bandwidth, characteristic of echolocation calls emitted by bats tracking prey. Lastly, the researchers provided further evidence that the high precision EFP’s can accurately estimate the time elapsed between a pair of sounds that simulate a sonar call and echo return, the acoustic cue for sonar target distance measurement. Thus, synchronous firing of a population of neurons can mediate microsecond precision of sound analysis in echolocation tasks, which also bears implications for other types of auditory processing in a wide range of animal species.

These findings are described in the article entitled Neural timing of stimulus events with microsecond precision, recently published in the journal PLOS Biology.


  1. Fenton, M.B., and Simmons, N. (2014). Bats: a world of science and mystery (University of Chicago Press).
    Griffin, D. (1958). Listening in the dark: the acoustic orientation of bats and men (New Haven: Yale University Press).
  2. Luo, J., Macias, S., Ness, T.V., Einevoll, G.T., Zhang, K., and Moss, C.F. (2018). Neural timing of stimulus events with microsecond precision. PLoS Biol. 16, e2006422.
  3. Moss, C.F., and Schnitzler, H.-U. (1995). Behavioral studies of auditory information processing. In Hearing by Bats, A.N. Popper, and R.R. Fay, eds. (New York: Springer-Verlag), pp. 87–145.
  4. Simmons, J.A. (1973). The resolution of target range by echolocating bats. J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 54, 157–173.
  5. Simmons, J.A. (2017). Theories about target ranging in bat sonar. Acoust. Today 13, 43–51.
  6. Suga, N. (2015). Neural processing of auditory signals in the time domain: Delay-tuned coincidence detectors in the mustached bat. Hear. Res. 324, 19–36.

About The Author

Jinhong Luo

Jinhong Luo studies the neurobiology of echolocating bats at the Johns Hopkins University and has started his own lab at the Central China Normal University.

Cynthia F. Moss

Cynthia F. Moss is a Professor in Psychological and Brain Sciences, with joint appointments in Neuroscience and Mechanical Engineering. At Johns Hopkins, she directs the Comparative Neural Systems and Behavior Laboratory, aka the Bat Lab. Moss received a B.S. (summa cum laude) from the University of Massachusetts, Amherst and a Ph.D. from Brown University. She was a Postdoctoral Fellow at the University of Tübingen, Germany, and a Research Fellow at Brown University before joining the faculty at Harvard University. At Harvard, Moss received the Phi Beta Kappa teaching award and was named the Morris Kahn Associate Professor. She later moved to the University of Maryland, where she was a Professor in the Department of Psychology and Institute for Systems Research until 2014. At Maryland, Moss served as Director of the interdepartmental graduate program in Neuroscience and Cognitive Science. She was recognized in 2010 with the University of Maryland Regents Faculty Award for Research and Creativity. In 2017, she received the Hartmann Award in Auditory Neuroscience and in 2018, she received the James McKeen Cattell Award, which supports her current sabbatical leave at Hong Kong University of Science and Technology.

Speak Your Mind!


Market-Level Effects Of Firm-Level Adaptation And Intermediation In Networked Markets Of Fresh Foods

The increasing trend in urban population has placed food security as a major concern for creating sustainable cities. Developing countries are not the exception. Developing countries are also showing a dramatic increase of their urban centers, which will augment food access issues in the coming years, especially for the poor. Food supply chains in developing […]

Bridging The History Of Climate Change And Human Society: A Case From Imperial China

Geographical environment, especially climate change, has long been one of the most important driving forces in the evolution of human history. Climate change could cause wide and profound impacts on human society at multiple spatio-temporal scales through its direct effects on heat resources, hydrology, soil, disasters, and further interactions with social subsystems. Investigating the role […]

Hybrid Materials As Potential NIR Absorbers For Organic Electronics

Modern society is largely a plastic-based culture in which organic (carbon-based) plastics have become more ubiquitous than other common materials such as metals, glass, or ceramics. As a result, some have postulated that there is sufficient justification to refer to the period beginning with the 20th century as the Age of Plastics. Although common organic […]

Managing Soil After A Fire

Fire is a natural element of ecosystems that has shaped world biomes as we know them today. With the exception of polar areas, fire affects all ecosystems with more or less periodicity. Fire appeared with vascular plants (420 million years ago) and started to be used by hominins 1.6 million years ago. The human use […]

Toward Successful Academic-Industry Collaboration in Energy Research

In the midst of a global energy transition, collaborations between academics and practitioners are becoming increasingly important. While these partnerships have primarily served to validate scientific research in real-world settings until very recently, they are now seen as essential for solving complex real-world problems, such as the energy transition. Previous research on the topic of […]

A Natural Language Processing Technique To Detect Ineffective Or Harmful Medical Devices

When drugs or devices enter the market, we want to be sure that there is effective, rapid post-market surveillance of adverse events in order to understand the risks attached to these products. In this paper, we show how our patented Boomerang NLP technology, a blend of natural language processing and machine learning techniques, can effectively […]

BIOCARB-4-FOOD: Exploring New Marine Food Ingredients

Food science and technology has experienced dramatic changes during the last century, which have been partly driven by new lifestyle trends and eating habits, as well as more specific consumer demands. It has been estimated that food consumption will grow approximately 70% by 2050 [1], while, on the other hand, natural resources are becoming scarcer. […]