Does Progesterone Increase Women’s Disgust Sensitivity?

How do we avoid becoming sick? Several lines of evidence suggest that the emotion of disgust helps to stop us from becoming sick by reducing our contact with sources of pathogens. This function of disgust may explain why many of the things that trigger disgust particularly strongly, such as feces, rotten food, and body fluids, are sources of pathogens, and that these things trigger disgust similarly across cultures.

But why does our disgust sensitivity, the extent to which we are disgusted by typically disgusting objects, smells, or situations, sometimes change over time? One hypothesis is that, at least in women, disgust sensitivity might be tied to changes in hormone levels, and progesterone in particular, that vary over the menstrual cycle.

This progesterone-linked disgust sensitivity is thought to occur because progesterone suppresses women’s immune system. This reduced immune function might trigger behavioral responses, such as increased disgust sensitivity, to compensate. However, early studies supporting this “Compensatory Prophylaxis Hypothesis” suffered from potentially important methodological limitations. For example, they either tested only a small number of women or estimated progesterone levels, rather than measuring them directly from urine or saliva.

To address these limitations of previous research, a recent study by Benedict Jones’ research group at the University of Glasgow had three hundred and seventy-five women fill out a widely-used disgust sensitivity questionnaire (the Three Domain Disgust Scale) weekly, on up to ten different weeks. In each of these test sessions, these women provided a saliva sample, which was analyzed for the hormones estradiol, progesterone, cortisol, and testosterone.

Analyses of these longitudinal data revealed no evidence that disgust sensitivity tracked changes in women’s hormone levels. These results challenge the hypothesis that women’s pathogen disgust increases when progesterone levels are high. Jones and colleagues also found no evidence that women who had higher progesterone levels in general showed greater disgust sensitivity.

This is not the first work Jones and colleagues have published that has found little support for the hypothesis that raised progesterone triggers behaviors that function to minimize contact with sources of illness. In another recent study, they used the same type of design to investigate whether women reported greater aversions to individuals displaying facial cues of illness, such as pallor, when their progesterone levels were raised. Again, Jones and colleagues found no evidence that raised progesterone triggered illness-avoidance behaviors. Although they found that women demonstrated strong aversions to even subtle facial cues of illness, there was no evidence that the strength of these aversions was regulated by progesterone.

Of course, Jones and colleagues’ results do not rule out the possibility that some specific types of illness-avoidance behaviors that were not considered in these studies are linked to progesterone (or other hormone) levels in some women. Nonetheless, their results do suggest that progesterone-linked illness-avoidance behaviors may be less common and less pronounced than was previously thought.

These findings are described in the article entitled Hormonal correlates of pathogen disgust: testing the compensatory prophylaxis hypothesis, recently published in the journal Evolution and Human BehaviorThis work was conducted by Benedict C. Jones, Claire I. Fisher, Anthony J. Lee, and Lisa M. DeBruine from the University of GlasgowAmanda C. Hahn from Humboldt State UniversityHongyi Wang from East China Normal University, and Michal Kandrik and Joshua M. Tybur from VU Amsterdam and the Institute for Brain and Behavior Amsterdam.

About The Author

Benedict C. Jones

Benedict C. Jones is the Chair Of Psychology (Centre for Cognitive Neuroimaging) at the Institute of Neuroscience & Psychology of the University of Glagow.


Speak Your Mind!


Scientists Create Enzyme Capable Of Eating And Breaking Down Plastic

Plastic pollution is a severe crisis plaguing much of the globe. A new enzyme created by a team of researchers may offer a solution to this problem, enabling the full recycling of plastic bottle, something that currently isn’t possible. The plastic eating enzyme was inadvertently created through a joint research project involving teams of researchers […]

What Is Black Tourmaline?

Black tourmaline is a particular variant of tourmaline, a crystalline borosilicate mineral. It is thought that the particular hue of black tourmaline is due to traces of titanium embedded in the minerals molecular structure. Black tourmaline, sometimes referred to as schorl,  is one of the most popular semi-precious gemstones in the world and it is commonly […]

How One Plant Is Making Water Safe To Drink

Water is the most important commodity to sustain life on earth, but because of climate change, rapid urbanization, and industrialization, the sources of potable water are rapidly decreasing or becoming contaminated. Nonavailability of potable drinking water is one of the major causes of death, especially among children. According to recent estimates, about 25,000 people die […]

Revealing The Reasons Behind Clinical Resemblances Among Patients With Different Imprinting Disorders Leading To Growth Restriction

In the human genome, genetic information is carried on two copies (two chromosomes), each copy being inherited from one of the parents. For most genes, both copies (maternal and paternal) are expressed equally. However, it has been shown that ~150 human genes have been expressed from either the paternal or the maternal chromosome but not […]

Admixed Populations: How To Correct For Ancestry Bias In Genetic Association Studies

Admixed populations pose a special challenge in genetic association studies due to the different proportions of a contribution of two or more ancestries. In the classic design of case-control studies, allele frequencies between disease and healthy subjects are compared; however, spurious associations not related to causative loci can be obtained by unmeasured population substructure. The […]

Making Sense Of Quantum Mechanics: Geometric Quantum Theory

The theory of quantum mechanics lies at the basis of our modern understanding of how microscopic particles such as electrons and atomic nuclei behave. Despite this fact, controversy on what it actually says about the physical world has accompanied the further development of the theory and its various off-springs up to today. Perhaps the main […]

The Role Of DDX3X In The Immune System

The innate immune system establishes a first-line defense against invading pathogenic microorganisms. The pathogens are sensed by dedicated antigen receptors. These receptors subsequently emit signals that reprogram cells of the immune system, preparing them for combat. Enabling cells to increase their immunological performance requires them to turn on sometimes hundreds of genes and repress others […]