Building Performance Assessment For Earthquakes Breaks New Ground With Study On Critical Orientation Using Lateral Force Analysis

One of the main purposes of the earthquake-related standards (e.g. EAK 2003; CEN 2004; Regulatory Guide 1.92 2006; NTC 2008; ASCE 2014) is to provide guidelines for the safe design and construction of structures against seismic loads. Modern standard provisions, however, are restricted by the current level of knowledge.

One aspect in which our knowledge is still limited is the ability to predict the exact location of the next earthquake. Taking this into account, in order to reassure that our structure will be able to resist a future earthquake generated at any location, the worst possible direction of attack should be studied. In the worst direction, we refer to the direction that will cause the most unfavorable effect on the structure.

The term angle of seismic incidence is used to refer to the orientation of a seismic action with respect to the building as represented in Figure 1 and denoted as θ. The angle θ that results in the most unfavorable effect is termed critical angle of incidence.

Figure 1. The angle of seismic incidence (θ) is the angle between the building’s structural axes, X and Y, and the input seismic action. Credit: Despoina Skoulidou

Most of the existing seismic provisions recognize the importance of the critical angle of incidence and require from the practitioners to account for it. However, the critical angle of incidence is not easy to define. Several studies performed during the past years have proven that each building has different critical angles of incidence that also vary for the different parameters (e.g. column force, story displacement etc).

Additionally, each seismic action has been found to cause the most unfavorable demand under a different angle of incidence. Moreover, several structural characteristics affect the critical angle, such as the simulation of the materials when the building is analyzed with nonlinear material properties. Thus, it results that is it not possible to know the critical angle a priori.

Since straightforward solutions to derive the critical angle of incidence are practically inexistent for most of the analysis procedures allowed by the standards, the practitioners are required to perform parametric analysis by considering multiple angles of incidence in order to derive the critical one. Such an approach, however, appears to be impractical and sometimes impossible for regular use.

Continuous studies with respect to the definition of the critical angle have resulted in the derivation of useful solutions to the problem (Menun and Der Kiureghian (1998), Athanatopoulou (2005)). Such a solution was also derived for the simplest and most frequently used method of analysis, the Lateral Force Analysis, and will be presented herein base on the original paper by Skoulidou and Romao (2017). The procedure will be presented for the case of a single story structure, while its extension for multi-story buildings accompanied by examples of the application can be found in the original document.

In LFA the seismic action corresponds to an acceleration response spectrum, which is a normalized average spectrum. The acceleration response spectrum consists of a four-branched equation, which is a function of the fundamental structural period along a given direction. An example of an acceleration response spectrum is presented in Figure 2.

Figure 2. Acceleration response spectrum. Credit: Despoina Skoulidou

The spectral acceleration, Sa, that corresponds to the fundamental period is then multiplied by the mass in order to calculate the input seismic force, F, along the respective direction.

                    (1)

Moreover, in LFA the building is modeled using the finite element method and considering linear elastic material properties. This modeling technique allows for the full description of the static behavior of the building based on its principal reference system. In the principal reference system, the uncoupled fundamental structural period, Tunc, of the building along any direction has been proven to fall on an ellipse, and thus it can be described by well-known mathematical expressions, as a function of the respective direction (or the angle of incidence, θ):

(2)

where TI and TII, correspond to the fundamental periods of the building along the two principal directions.

By substituting the expression of the uncoupled fundamental period, defined in Equation 2, in the expression of the spectrum and multiply it by the mass, as shown in Equation 1, the input seismic force is obtained only as a function of the angle of seismic incidence:
      (3)

Hence, the maximization of the input force can be deduced by maximizing Equation 3. Such a maximization can be achieved by equalizing the derivative of Equation 3 to zero and solving with respect to the angle. The obtained angle is the critical angle of incidence.

These findings are described in the article entitled Critical orientation of earthquake loading for building performance assessment using lateral force analysis, published in the journal Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering. This work was led by Despoina Skoulidou from the University of Porto.

References:

  • ASCE (2014) Seismic evaluation and retrofit of existing buildings (ASCE/SEI 41-13). American Society of Civil Engineers, Reston, Virginia, USA
  • Athanatopoulou AM (2005) Critical orientation of three correlated seismic components. Engineering Structures 27(2): 301–312
  • EAK (2003) Greek code for earthquake resistant design of structures. Ministry of Environment, Planning and Public Works. Athens, Greece
  • CEN (2004) EN1998-1 Eurocode 8: Design of structures for earthquake resistance, part 1: general rules, seismic actions and rules for buildings. European Committee for Standardization
  • Federal Emergency Management Agency (2012) Seismic performance assessment of buildings. FEMA P58 report, Washington, DC
  • Menun C, Der Kiureghian A (1998) A Replacement for the 30%, 40%, and SRSS rules for multicomponent seismic analysis. Earthquake Spectra. 14(1): 153-163
  • NTC (2008) Norme tecniche per le costruzioni. Decreto del Ministero delle Infrastrutture. Supplemento ordinario n.30 alla Gazzetta Ufficiale della Repubblica Italiana n.29 del 4/02/2008, Italy (in Italian)
  • Regulatory Guide 1.92 (2006) U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research. Washington, DC
  • Skoulidou, D., & Romão, X. (2017). Critical orientation of earthquake loading for building performance assessment using lateral force analysis. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering15(12), 5217-5246.

About The Author

Despoina Skoulidou

Despoina Skoulidou is a researcher at the University of Porto | UP · Departamento de Engenharia Civil.

Speak Your Mind!

READ THIS NEXT

Do Addicts Have Free Will? What Research Says About The Nature Of Addiction

“Going cold turkey” and “kicking the habit” are familiar idioms, but their origins are not. Some (and perhaps many) heroin addicts quit on their own and do so all at once, hence the goosebumps and spasms that often accompany withdrawal. In contrast, no one goes “cold turkey” from diabetes, heart disease, or schizophrenia. No one […]

Towards Obtaining Molecular Snapshots Of Biological Processes In Real Time

Biological functions and processes in organisms including human are carried out by many biomolecules.  Those biomolecules are proteins, DNA, RNA, polysugars, lipids and many small molecules like vitamins and other metabolites etc.  It is more often that we know about the chemical compositions of those players than we know about their three-dimensional (3D) architectures.  However, […]

miR-218-5p As A New Player In Uterine Vascular Transformation During Pregnancy

The placenta is a transient organ that serves as the interface between the fetus and the mother. It has a multitude of critical roles in maintaining and protecting the developing fetus throughout the pregnancy. Specifically, it facilitates the exchange of gases, nutrients, and waste products, serves as an endocrine organ producing a number of pregnancy-associated […]

The Role Smell Plays In Sexual Arousal

Human olfaction is fairly sophisticated and sensitive. We can most likely detect approximately one trillion different odorants compared to several million colors and a half million different tones, and we are able to detect odors at very low concentrations, (e.g., 0.2 ppb for some molecules). Further, the nature of the information provided via smell seems […]

Shield Volcano: Interesting Facts, Examples, And Diagrams

A shield volcano is the largest type of volcano on Earth, with low viscosity lava flows and a wide broad shape. The low viscosity, runny, nature of the lava means it travels in streams far from the source and covers many square miles. The largest volcano in the entire world, Mauna Loa in Hawaii, is […]

Transparent Coatings Incorporating Light-Guiding Architectures Boost Energy Generation In Solar Cells

Driven to increase the power output from solar cells – one of the most important sources of renewable energy globally – the Hosein Research Group at Syracuse University has developed a new type of polymer coating that enables a solar cell to convert more light into electricity. The coating consists of 1000s of microscale fiber […]

Wood Spirit, An Alert Signal For Plants Under Attack

There is a plant-protecting spirit blowing through the air. If you breathe in carefully now you will smell… wood spirit! Long believed to be a simple by-product of degradation of a plant cell wall, new results show that methanol is a signal that tells surrounding plants to activate their defenses against pathogens and predators. Methanol […]