Celestial Mechanics, Relative Equilibria, And Many Difficult Problems

Celestial mechanics is a branch in the intersection of mathematics and physics, where the main goal is to describe the motion of any number of bodies (in a three dimensional space), characterized by some physical attributes like mass or electric charge and with some specific geometrical form, which interact each other by a law dependent of the previous factors. All this is usually called a system of particles.

To start work with a system of particles, once the geometry and properties of the bodies involved have been established, the next step is precise a mathematical function that represents the law of interaction of the bodies, which is called the potential function. At this point, a system of equations is obtained which involves positions, velocities, and accelerations. With all above, the one interested in attacking such a problem might just have to start praying…

The more usual situation study in celestial mechanics is known as the N-body problem, where are N point masses, i.e., bodies perfectly spherical and with mass as a single physical property, denoted by m1, …, mN moving in a d-dimensional Euclidean space, although we will be most interested in the cases d = 2 and 3. If the locations of the masses are written as x1, x2, …, xN,
and we let rij = ∥xixj denote the distances between mass i and j. The interaction between the bodies is given by the Newtonian potential:

Then the equations are:

Equation (2) is usually called the N-body equations, Newton’s equations, or the N-body problem (Meyer et al., 2009). The history of the N-body problem has nearly three centuries of contributions from some of the most brilliant minds, from Newton to Poincare. But this is not the most fascinating feature of this problem.

 

After all, equation (2) has been solved only for N = 1 and N = 2, but the N-body problem is an open problem when considering three or more bodies. Anyone seduced by celestial mechanics could start to imagine configurations of three objects moving in space: for example three stars, or a star, a planet and a satellite, or the nucleus of a Helium atom together with its two electrons. As we said before, the spatial positions of these points are represented by three vectors x1, x2, x3, and the masses of the objects are denoted m1, m2, m3. The masses move so that their positions xi are functions of time t.

Under these conditions, equation (2) is rewritten as:

The right-hand sides should be multiplied through by a very famous physical constant, the Newton’s Universal Constant of Gravitation, denoted G. But in mathematics, through a rescaling, we allowed to set G = 1. For N = 1 and N = 2 with some simple tools of calculus proved that the trajectories of the bodies must be some kind of conic, but then, for N = 3, what are all the possible trajectories?

Figure 2: The three body problem is considered the first example of a chaotic system, as very few analytical solutions are known for this problem. Credit: John A. Arredondo

The previous question is so hard, that it has only been possible to get an answer for some particular situations: equals masses, specific configurations of the bodies, and so on. One of these special configurations was established by Euler and Lagrange and is called the “Problem of the Relative Equilibria,” a configuration of the bodies where they remain in equilibria in a rotating system or a configuration where position and acceleration vectors are proportional, with the same constant of proportionality.

This particular problem is similar in awkwardness to the general N-body problem, as it is still open for N ≥ 6. But the multiple applications of such configurations, especially in the design of trajectories for spatial journeys, motived Steve Smale to include in their list of problems to be solved in the 21st century (Smale, 2000). In this list, as the sixth problem stated, we must prove the finiteness of the number of relative equilibria in celestial mechanics.

To find relative equilibria or, more generally, some result for the N-body problem, is not only of mathematical interest but is also very important in applications. Thus, the description of the system of particles must be as accurate as possible, but the potential function in equation (1) works only for spherical bodies. Moreover, we know that the equations of classical mechanics fail to describe the behavior of, for example, the perihelion advance of Mercury. So, what can we do? Two questions appear:

Figure 3: Lagrange found a solution for the three-body problem where each body moves in an elliptical trajectory while the three bodies preserve an equilateral triangle configuration. Credit: John A. Arredondo

1. How to model (for example) a satellite orbiting the Earth, knowing that Earth, and planets in general, are far from being perfectly spherical objects.

2. The physical theory that generalizes Newtonian mechanics is general relativity. Then, why not use this to achieve a better description of the dynamics of the planetary system and objects like quasars, galaxies, and black holes?

The answer to the first question, we need to find a potential function for every specific problem. This is done by solving the Poisson equation, which is a difficult problem in partial differential equations, from which is known that the simplest potential function is that for interaction between spherical bodies (Arredondo et al., 2012).

For the second question, unlike Newtonian mechanics, in general relativity, even the simplest case of a two-body problem cannot be solved.

A way to overcome the obstacles described above is to seek a continuous, classic description of the problem, but with an effective potential: a potential function which is consistent with the experimental observations. Doing this, we get an N-body problem where the interaction between the bodies is described by a potential of the form:

where r is the distance between the bodies, and A, B, α and β are positive constants. These kinds of potentials are called quasi-homogeneous. Expression (4) generalizes several well-known quasi-homogeneous potentials which model problems in biology, astrophysics, or chemistry as such as Birkhoff, Manev, Van der Waals, Libhoff, Schwarzschild, Lennard-Jones, the classical Newton, and Coulomb (see Sthephani et al., 2003).

Using any of those potentials, equation (2) becomes more difficult than with the Newtonian potential, since even the Kepler problem does not have an analytical solution. All this forces us to look much deeper for tools to get answers. Although this search is a very thorny road, the reward is amazing.

These findings are described in the article entitled Relative equilibria in quasi-homogeneous planar three-body problem, recently published in the journal Advances in Space Research. This work was conducted by John A. Arredondo from Fundación Universitaria Konrad Lorenz.

About The Author

John A. Arredondo

John is a research associate at the Fundación Universitaria Konrad Lorenz, Department of Mathematics amd Ingeniere.

Speak Your Mind!

READ THIS NEXT

What Do They Get Out Of It? The Emotional Experience Of Providing Social Support

Students and faculty in Western Washington University’s Psychology Department examined the experience of giving social support in two countries (the US and Singapore) using an innovative methodology called the Day Reconstruction Method or DRM, a technique originally developed by Princeton psychologist and Nobel Prize winner Daniel Kahneman. The study was recently published in the journal […]

Anatomical Heart: Learn The Heart Through Illustrations

The anatomical human heart is the organ responsible for cycling blood throughout the human body, providing the tissues in the body with the oxygen they need. The heart is an integral part of the circulatory system, along with the blood vessels, blood, lymph and lymphatic vessels. The heart works to circulate blood throughout the body, […]

Vesta’s Crust And The Tale Of The Birth Of The Solar System

Investigating the birth of the Solar System is a bit like investigating the crime scene of a “cold case,” where the passage of time, here just about four and a half billions of years, canceled most traces left by the events we are trying to reconstruct. Luckily for us, the Solar System plays fair and […]

Solution Deposited Sn Doped Co3O4 Thin Film For Glucose Detection

According to the WHO, diabetes is among the 10 leading causes of death in adults. In the treatment of this disease, a regular glucose monitoring is required. Hence, glucose detection must be accurate, rapid and affordable. Research on glucose sensor has increased considerably in order to provide affordable sensors with good sensitivity and selectivity. Among […]

My Science Life: Assistant Professor John W. Jamieson, Canada Research Chair In Marine Geology

Welcome to the My Science Life feature of Dr. John W. Jamieson, Assistant Professor and Canada Research Chair in Marine Geology at Memorial University of Newfoundland. I am an Economic Geologist that specializes in marine mineral resources and seafloor hydrothermal systems. I grew up in Edmonton, Alberta. B.Sc. (Honours Geology) – University of Alberta M.Sc. (Geology) […]

Scientists Develop Squirtable Glue That Seals Wounds In Seconds

Most wounds that require surgeries are done with stitches or staples employed to hold the wound shut. However, two new medical technologies have developed techniques to heal wounds without the use of either staples or sutures. A new medical device created through a joint project done by the University of Sydney and several American universities […]

Flexible Substrates For DNA Arrays

Array fabrication technologies date back to the early 1990s when Affymetrix first used ultraviolet light to control the stepwise synthesis of biopolymers from a surface.[1] The most commercially successful result of this technology was high-density arrays of DNA. At the time, DNA arrays were one of the most efficient ways to detect and measure nucleic […]